Arcade Fire - The Suburbs Review

The Suburbs

Arcade Fire

Release Date: 2nd Aug, 2010
Label: Mercury
Genre: Indie
Purchase on Amazon

If 2007's Neon Bible was supposed to be Arcade Fire's difficult second album, it didn't show. Top marks from a cavalcade of critical tomes saw the Montreal septet's sequel to their breakthrough debut long-player of 2004, Funeral, received with just as much reverence as its predecessor. So what of The Suburbs, arriving after another three-year period which saw its makers record in both their hometown and New York?


Even on a cursory listen, a water-testing foray into its 16 tracks, it's immediately apparent that this is an album unlike either that came before it. While Funeral and Neon Bible were great sets, their strengths laid primarily in a handful of stand-out selections: Wake Up and Power Out on the former, No Cars Go and Black Wave among the highs on the latter.


The Suburbs appears to have been conceived as a whole in a manner considerably more studied than the band's previous attempts. Its sequencing is perfect, the contrast between fiery punk number Month of May and the following acoustic strum of Wasted Hours the most prominent instance of how unlikely tracks are segued with uncommon skill. It's a convergent collection, too, the opening title-track reprised come the record's quiet climax, comprising an intro to its earlier, fuller version. Put The Suburbs on repeat and days could pass before the urge to change the record takes hold.

If that sounds like excessive hyperbole, well, you're probably yet to hear The Suburbs in full. Its stand-alone tracks, as played on radio stations the world over in anticipation of this release, far from tell the whole tale. Month of May, as implied above, is the album's frenetic fulcrum, but stylistically it's detached from the majority. Its opener sets a tone of sorts, but it's one the band has some fun with, filtering influences ranging from Springsteen to Depeche Mode into songs that operate on a level of subconscious infiltration that surpasses the earworm qualities of Funeral's most immediate cuts. Case in point: the propulsive Ready to Start, which somehow balances an air of anguish with triumphant exclamation; City With No Children takes lyrical cues from dark places but allows instrumental light enough to seep into the mix, creating an end product that's like the finest Hold Steady song never written.

A brace of two-part pieces, Half Light and Sprawl, is indicative of Arcade Fire's successful progression to a new dominion of creativity. The former's string-soaked flourishes are surely set to replace The Cinematic Orchestra's To Build a Home as the soundtrack to a few thousand television trailers; Sprawl, meanwhile, confirms this album's conceptual direction atop shimmering synth lines. Alienation and abandonment, social stereotypes and fractured fantasies. All tropes present and correct, the encapsulating title alluding to an outsider status manifested both physically and, more pertinently, emotionally.

I need the darkness / can you please cut the lights? Lines like this might seem trite, or at least insincere, coming from a band that's enjoyed worldwide commercial success, that's been on general public display for some five years plus. But it's important to remember that Arcade Fire's journey from underground obscurity to chart-topping acclaim has been at a trajectory decidedly different to many a music industry heavyweight, more happy accident than orchestrated intent. Emerging from a previously unexplored beyond, their story has always been theirs alone to tell. And The Suburbs is their most thrillingly engrossing chapter yet; a complex, captivating work that, several cycles down the line, retains the magic and mystery of that first tentative encounter. You could call it their OK Computer. But it's arguably better than that.

Reviewed by Mike Diver

About The Artist

Arcade Fire

Arcade Fire is an orchestral indie rock band which formed in Montreal, Quebec, Canada in 2003. The band consists of Win Butler (vocals, guitar, piano), Régine Chassagne (vocals, accordion, keyboards, hurdy gurdy, drums), Richard Reed Parry (bass, guitar), William Butler (keyboards, guitar), Tim Kingsbury (bass), Sarah Neufeld (violin), and Jeremy Gara (drums). Howard Bilerman, who played drums on the album Funeral, has since moved on to other projects. Montreal percussionist Dane Mills performed on the EP and in early live shows. As of May 2005, the touring band includes horn player Pietro Amato (who is in Bell Orchestre and Torngat) and violinist Owen Pallett. Pallett has also opened for their shows, appearing as the one-man band Final Fantasy. The band’s trademark fashion is the waistcoat, giving them an air of "frumpiness". When asked about the rumour that the band's name refers to a fire in an arcade, Win Butler replied: "It's not a rumour, it's based on a story that someone told me. It's not an actual event, but one that I took to be real. I would say that it's probably something that the kid made up, but at the time I believed him." Win Butler and his brother Will grew up in Texas. Band formation Arcade Fire formed around the husband and wife duo of Win Butler and Régine Chassagne. Joining together as recently as mid-2003, the current line-up solidified in late 2003/early 2004, when their first full-length album Funeral was recorded. Before this an eponymous EP (often referred to by fans as the Us Kids Know EP) had been sold at early shows. The EP was subsequently remastered and given a full release once the band started becoming more prominent. Arcade Fire are known for their enthralling live performances, as well as its use of a large number of musical instruments. In addition to mainstays guitar, drums, and bass guitar, members play piano, violin, viola, cello, double bass, xylophone, keyboard, French horn, accordion, and harp. With several able musicians, the band take most of their instrumental diversity on tour and members switch instrumental duties throughout their shows. The number of instruments, along with a wide set of musical influences has provided a substantial number of resources on which to draw from during the recording process. The promise showed by the band in its live shows allowed it to land a record contract with Chapel Hill-based independent record label Merge Records. Funeral Their first full-length album, Funeral, debuted in September 2004 in the USA and in February 2005 in the UK, and was very highly acclaimed by critics. The title of the debut album was chosen because of the deaths of several relatives of band members during recording. These events created a sombre atmosphere which influenced songs such as "Une année sans lumière" ("A Year without Light"), "In the Backseat", and "Haïti", Chassagne's elegy to her lost homeland. Without a major label backing, the success of the band and the album Funeral has been acclaimed as an Internet phenomenon. After a 9.7 rating from Pitchfork, Merge Records sold out their inventory of Funeral and it became the label's first album in the Billboard 200 chart. An early tip from David Bowie was also influential. The band booked small clubs for their 2004 tour but growing interest forced many venue changes, far beyond the band's expectations, and continued internationally into mid-2005 throughout the United States, Canada, Europe, and the SummerSonic Festival in Japan. Taking much of the summer of 2005 off, the band made four key festival appearances at the Coachella Music Festival, the Sasquatch Music Festival, the Lowlands Festival and Lollapalooza. Funeral graced several top ten album lists in 2004. This continued in 2005 with the release of Funeral in the UK, Japan and Australia. The MTV2 2005 Review hosted by Zane Lowe named Funeral Album of the Year, and NME named Funeral Number 2 in their list of 2005's best albums and "Rebellion (Lies)" the best track. By November 2005, Funeral had gone gold in both Canada and the UK and sold in excess of half a million copies worldwide, a phenomenal number for an independent release with minimal television or radio exposure. It has also surpassed Neutral Milk Hotel's In the Aeroplane Over the Sea as the biggest selling Merge Records album to date. Arcade Fire were featured on the April 4, 2005 cover of Time Magazine's Canadian edition, and hailed as a band who "helped put Canadian music on the world map". On May 1, 2005, the band performed to approximately 15,000 fans at the Coachella Valley Music & Arts Festival; their performance is often viewed as the highlight of Coachella 2005. In May 2005, the band signed a short-term publishing contract with EMI for Funeral and in June, the band released a new single, "Cold Wind", on Six Feet Under, Vol. 2: Everything Ends, the second soundtrack album to the popular HBO series Six Feet Under. The BBC used the track "Wake Up" on an advertisement for their autumn 2005 season and they are now using the tracks "Rebellion (Lies)" and "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)" on adverts in January 2006. On September 9, 2005, the band appeared on the UK/US TV special Fashion Rocks, where David Bowie joined them for "Wake Up". This recording, as well as recordings by the collaboration of Bowie's "Life On Mars" and "Five Years", were made available on the iTunes Music Store in a virtual live EP. The same trip to New York City took them to the Late Show with David Letterman and a concert in Central Park. The Central Park Show had a surprise appearance by Bowie, and capped a great touring season for the band. On September 11, 2005, Arcade Fire appeared on the long running BBC music series Top of the Pops, performing "Rebellion (Lies)" - on what was one of the band's first mainstream UK television appearances. The band also performed to a TV audience in Paris for Canal +, and the show was later screened on UK television channel, Channel 4. The band has scored two Number One songs on MTV2(UK)NME CHART SHOW, with "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" and a three week run with "Wake Up". However this followed Rough Trade Records (the label who distributes Arcade Fire's music in the UK) deciding at the last minute not to release "Wake Up" on CD, and only on 7" vinyl. Arcade Fire's song "Wake Up" was played immediately before the Irish rock group U2 opened their concerts on their 2005 Vertigo Tour; the band would subsequently open three shows for that tour, and at the third show, they appeared onstage during U2's encore to join them in a cover of Joy Division's Love Will Tear Us Apart. Their album Funeral and their single "Cold Wind" were respectively nominated for Grammys in the best Alternative Rock Album and Best Song Written for Television, Film, or Other Media categories (Six Feet Under, Vol. 2: Everything Ends). On April 2, 2006, in Halifax, Nova Scotia, they received the Juno Award for Songwriters Of The Year for three songs from Funeral: "Wake Up", "Rebellion (Lies)" and "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)". The band was nominated for, but not awarded, three Brit Awards: Best International Group, Best International Album and Best International Breakthrough Act. Arcade Fire have also recently made two appearances on Later with Jools Holland, a live show on the BBC. On December 27, 2005, Funeral was ranked #1 on MTV2's "50 Greatest Albums of the Year" in the United Kingdom. Arcade Fire then planned to begin recording a follow up to Funeral in the winter of 2005-2006, having bought an old church forty minutes from central Montreal which they converted into a studio. Neon Bible In mid-December 2006 www.neonbible.com went live containing nothing more than a phone number, 1-866-NEONBIBLE where people can listen to a new track called Intervention. Built in the style of customer support lines, the number has other features including a contest and a chance to talk to a live person at a specific time each week. Then in January 2007, they finally announced that the new album Neon Bible would be released March 5th in UK, March 6th in US. The announcement was made with a video in the album's website, with guitarist Richard Reed Parry using a gramophone and a paper mask of Parry's own face, and sitting on Win Butler´s chair. After the announcement of the album´s release, the website was updated with a streaming version of "Black Mirror", new art and a few phone messages sounding like the band´s members. So far, 3 singles have been released: Intervention, Keep The Car Running and No Cars Go. The band headlined the Latitude Festival in 2007, playing all of the hits and joined by Owen on violins On December 15, 2008, Arcade Fire released Miroir-Noir, a concert movie that includes live footage from the 2006-07 tours shot by Vincent Moon. A new song called Lenin appeared on the highly acclaimed compilation "Dark Was The Night", a release benefiting the Red Hot Organization, among other high tipped indie artists. The song is very straightforward, remembering the pre-Funeral material, and maybe showing direction for future releases. The band released their third album "The Suburbs" on August 2, 2010 in the UK and August 3, 2010 in the United States. It debuted at #1 in both countries. On February 13, 2011, the album won Album of the Year at the 53rd Grammy Awards.

Related Reviews

50 Comments

  1. Tiagosector 01 Feb 2012

    A perfect record, all of those songs are unique and memorable. [2]

  2. EdgeLike 22 Jan 2012

    they didn't top it yeah. they made its equal.

  3. matt1337c 22 Jan 2012

    Good album, but I don't think they're ever going to top Funeral. I don't blame them though; its hard to top one of the greatest albums of the decade.

  4. SofieVandepitte 16 Jan 2012

    Rococo ♥

  5. Confessions87 13 Jan 2012

    Probably the greatest and most significant album of the past few years, at least for me. The others would be Let England Shake, Have One On Me and Merriweather Post Pavilion.

  6. jennyferselene 09 Jan 2012

    creo q este es el mejor album de la banda espero q regresen pronto a mexico please!!!!!

  7. metalhybrid 30 Dec 2011

    A perfect record, all of those songs are unique and memorable.

  8. nareru 27 Dec 2011

    Bought the album today without even having heard any of Arcade Fire's songs.

  9. niqart 23 Dec 2011

    Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains) ♥ Wasted Hours ♥ Empty Room ♥ Rococo ♥ Half Light I ♥ Half Light II (No Celebration) ♥ Month Of May

  10. Brunoligado 20 Dec 2011

    In case anyone wonders... the deluxe version off of their site does NOT come with synchronised artwork, only the standard version.

  11. CookieSkatalite 05 Dec 2011

    I think this is their best album :) I like all the other ones too though

  12. GlacierOcean 28 Nov 2011

    This would be on par with Funeral if it was around 10 hours shorter.

  13. pravdt 26 Nov 2011

    awesome [612781237612783613618273681]

  14. ca-ro-li-na 23 Nov 2011

    love it

  15. Ampuhedron 20 Nov 2011

    Can someone tell me what the cover art is supposed to be? It looks to me like cartoon cats in that car...

  16. CharlieBroown 07 Nov 2011

    awesome [3]

  17. aelimeade 05 Nov 2011

    An awesome album that could be made better with a touch less reverb.

  18. JuliusNepos 07 Oct 2011

    Thematically the new OKC

  19. c0rdell 06 Oct 2011

    this album is starting to grown on me. Everything from Modern Man to Half Light 1 is perfect.

  20. Hyggor16 03 Oct 2011

    A year later, I can't believe how this album is still affecting me [2]

  21. Marucin666 30 Sep 2011

    awesome [2]

  22. BernardoVailati 29 Sep 2011

    I don't usually like rock or indie-rock, but this is simply amazing!

  23. timmerd 26 Sep 2011

    awesome

  24. gutierrezlewis 26 Sep 2011

    can't stop myself form listening to this album and the movie is a errie (think i spelled that wrong) look into the future. . . .

  25. zhelnerovich 22 Sep 2011

    "objectively"... Fail.

  26. Retrogums 19 Sep 2011

    @theblackjay I'm kidding, its just shit.

  27. theblackjay 19 Sep 2011

    @Retrogums: How would The Suburbs be "objectively their worst"? If you're looking at it objectively, this album has had much more success than their previous records, even winning a Grammy and a Juno for album of the year.

  28. theblackjay 19 Sep 2011

    A year later, I can't believe how this album is still affecting me.

  29. Scrumpel 15 Sep 2011

    Jesus christ, everyones entitled to an opinion, but to dismiss this album as 'their worst' just seems to be a trend at the moment. It's actually generally considered better than Neon Bible, which is an opinion I share. OK, Funeral is the dogs nuts, but this is a well crafted, ambitious, diverse album which still surpasses most of the other shit out there at the moment.

  30. shinohiro929 13 Sep 2011

    I love how all the songs in this album have been played many times almost equally.

  31. HyperMusic__ 12 Sep 2011

    Those who are saying that this is their worst piece are simply expressing a personal preference.This is it. (This coming from a user that has 2846 plays in her library.)

  32. Retrogums 10 Sep 2011

    @tape_rewinder I play bass, I know absolutely nothing.

  33. tape_rewinder 10 Sep 2011

    Those who are saying that this is their worst piece are simply having the "I-can-play-guitar-I-know-everything-about-music" syndrome.

  34. Chris-Blitz 10 Sep 2011

    250 plays and still feels fresh.

  35. schrikk 06 Sep 2011

    This is the best CD i own.

  36. Retrogums 06 Sep 2011

    @Rockthejazzbar It is objectively their worst though.

  37. Rockthejazzbar 05 Sep 2011

    I don't understand why people, who pretend to be fans of a band, start to compare albums and say things like "easily their worst" with such a sense of superiority. It disgusts me. You're allowed to have a preference, but that still doesn't mean their other work is worse, as if you're the only one in the universe who knows certain things other people don't.

  38. Cheekeemunkee 31 Aug 2011

    favorite album. ever. didn't grab me at first, but once it did........and the 2 new tracks on the deluxe version are just about perfect. for once, i'm actually glad a band released a deluxe version of an already incredible album with additions.

  39. PT-Fox 25 Aug 2011

    easily their worst.[2] and yet it was still one of the best albums of 2010. Very impressive band.

  40. Dysrianism 23 Aug 2011

    easily their worst.

  41. constellator 20 Aug 2011

    this is my favourite album right now! i can't stop listening to it : )

  42. target-uk 17 Aug 2011

    A year on, and it still rocks my world :D.

  43. JuliusNepos 15 Aug 2011

    so much better then Neon bible... I am starting to love this band again [2]

  44. bernlin2000 11 Aug 2011

    Arcade Fire simply rule, I love all of their work. I was so happy to see them finally get recognition from the Grammy's (even if their awards are a joke, anyhow)

  45. schrikk 04 Aug 2011

    YES YES YES YES YES !

  46. HeroGothamNeeds 30 Jul 2011

    This band have a formula and it's brilliant

  47. kluk_jako_buk 26 Jul 2011

    I do really think that this is their best record...

  48. strokiana_radio 22 Jul 2011

    ai, ai, meus queridos...

  49. Honzeecheck 21 Jul 2011

    so much better then Neon bible... I am starting to love this band again

  50. jamie_q 16 Jul 2011

    I don't think you need to come to the suburbs to appreciate this album. I live in central London, one of the world's largest urbanised areas, and I still feel a big connection to this album from my childhood when I did grow up in the suburbs. That connection will never go away. [2]

Leave A Response